Lessons Information Resources Email Update Enquiry Desk Post-it Board PIPs Home Search



market photo
Decentralisation and Sustainable Livelihoods: James Manor (IDS)


 7.  Impact on Development:

A. Enhancing the impact of health, education and environmental programmes: We saw in section 5 how the uptake on health services can increase when elected local councillors explain their utility in terms that ordinary people can grasp. Good experiences on the health front, plus the ability of councillors to explain education, environmental and other programmes - and their adaptation of such programmes to local conditions -- can incline citizens towards greater acceptance of (and engagement with) those programmes too. Note also the growth, in many countries, of at least partially elected 'user committees' in the health, education, water and environmental sectors - committees which operate like elected decentralized councils.

B. Adapting development policies to local conditions and 'scaling up': Decentralized authorities are often able to adapt schemes devised at higher levels to distinctive conditions and needs within local arenas. They can inject local knowledge into them, and harmonize them with often quite constructive local arrangements for managing resources and addressing needs. When a success is achieved within one locality, the decentralized system provides a useful network for informing all localities of the success thus facilitating the 'scaling up'.

C. Alleviating poverty and contributing to the sustainable livelihood outcomes: This is an extremely complex issue, but in brief - democratic decentralization seldom assists in alleviating poverty which is the result of inequalities within lower-level arenas. This is because prosperous groups at the local level, who usually capture substantial power in decentralized authorities, are often more uncompromising in their attitudes to the poor than elites at higher levels. But note that this generalization does not apply when poorer groups at the local level are well-organised and politically aware - as they are, for example, in much of Latin America. Note also that decentralization often helps to reduce poverty which is the result of inequality between regions or localities to which power is devolved. It does so by giving deprived areas more equitable representation within national systems, and by ensuring a fairer distribution of resources across various areas.


PIP Home
Contents



 

 

 

 

 

D. Promoting economic growth: In some countries, technocrats assume that decentralization can help to accelerate economic growth. But the empirical evidence strongly suggests that its impact on growth is largely neutral - except in certain large conurbations where (for example) the development of industrial infrastructure may help.

E. Mobilizing local resources – financial capital: It is unrealistic to expect democratic decentralization to assist very much in mobilizing local resources - if by this we mean financial capital. (It can assist in mobilizing human resources - see section 7. F just below.) The reasons are complex, but the crucial problem is the understandable reluctance of elected representatives (especially but not only in newly created bodies) to levy new taxes. That would make the representatives unpopular and could undermine the legitimacy of the new bodies. Decentralizers who expect devolved tasks to be funded by new taxes put decentralized systems at risk by under-funding them.

F. Making development more sustainable: Given the difficulties which attend the mobilization of local financial capital, democratic decentralization tends to do little to enhance the sustainability of development in economic terms - although the erosion of popular reluctance to pay taxes helps somewhat. But it can assist in other ways. Since decentralized authorities often give citizens local development projects that they prefer, citizens tend to maintain them with care. And since decentralization helps to increase the uptake on (for example) health services, citizens using them increasingly recognise their benefits -- so that the increased uptake is sustained.



 


 Contents:
Background
Definitions and Concepts
Key Research Issues and Methodology
Essential Conditions for Success
Impact on Governance
Impact on Society
Impact on Development
Further Reading
Useful Internet Sources


   
   

DFID Logo
Disclaimer
Photos © Panos Pictures

  IDS Logo
© IDS 2000
www.livelihoods.org
Lessons Information Resources Email Update Enquiry Desk Post-it Board PIPs Home Search