Lessons Information Resources Email Update Enquiry Desk Post-it Board PIPs Home Search


Lessons

reading photo

Livelihood Substitution: Involving the poor in urban infrastructure and services development
Bangladesh, India, Pakistan, Ethiopia

 

Partners         
Start date
10 /2002
End date
09 /2004
Commitment (£)
£196,000
 
* Energy for Sustainable Development (ESD), UK
* Urban Resources Centre, Karachi, Pakistan.
* Chintan Environmental Research and Action Group, Delhi, India.
* Sanjay Gupta, Delhi, India
* MEGAN POWER Ltd. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Contacts
* Jonathan Rouse j.r.rouse@lboro.ac.uk Tel: +44 (0)1509 223749 / 222885
* Project website http://wedc.lboro.ac.uk/projects/new_projects3.php?id=73

Purpose

To understand the impact of urban infrastructure and services development on the livelihoods of the poor.
To consider how adverse impacts on the poor can be minimised or avoided altogether.
To raise the profile of the poor with organisations responsible for planning and implementing urban projects.


Lessons:
Livelihood Substitution: Mainstreaming the poor in urban infrastructure and services development. Inception report. J. Rouse with Dr. M. Ali. February 2003 PDF

Livelihoods Substitution project flier. January 2002 PDF

Urban development and livelihoods of the poor in Dhaka. Nasrin Khandoker and Jonathan Rouse Presented at the 30th WEDC International Conference, Vientiane, Lao PDR, 2004 DOC
Absorbing informal-sector entrepreneurs into improved urban services J. Rouse DOC
Livelihood Substitution DFID Inception Report PDF


Purpose
Lessons
Use of SL Approaches
Other Urban Projects
Contribute



Background and use of SL
This project focused on the affect on livelihoods when new urban infrastructure and services (I&S) are developed. Although I&S can bring critical health, environmental and social benefits, they can have a detrimental affect on the livelihood interests of some of the poor.

The project focussed on the following livelihoods groups :

- In Delhi and Hyderabad, India – the waste pickers who lose access to valuable waste when solid waste management is improved
- In Addis Ababba in Ethiopia - the traditional fuel suppliers who lose customers as a result of fuel-switching policies encouraging the use of kerosene
- In Dhaka, Bangladesh and Karachi, Pakistan - the rickshaw cyclists who lose work because they are barred access to new fast roads and flyovers.

At the heart of the project was 'Livelihood substitution' - where new livelihood opportunities are adopted by those who lose out by I&S. The project explored ways in which new livelihoods could be created for those who are detrimentally affected within the delivery of improved I&S, for example waste pickers enjoying better pay, rights, status and working conditions formally working with municipalities in sanitary waste management.

The fieldwork undertaken in Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Ethiopian was all structured around the Sustainable Livelihoods Approach (SLA). This enabled the researchers to disaggregate the activities and context of informal item sector entrepreneurs into assets (including financial, physical, natural, social and human), livelihood strategies and interaction with rules, laws, culture and official bodies (such as police and government).

While the SLA constituted the skeleton, participative approaches provided the flesh. Investigating issues through a ‘livelihoods’ lens must usually, by definition, be intrinsically participatory. The overseas research undertaken for this project was predominantly based around qualitative fieldwork, including semi-structured interviews, focus groups and observation.

All the outputs of this project have focused on the livelihoods of the poor. Livelihoods of the point of departure, from which they examine and analyse policy, infrastructure development, service delivery and mitigation measures.

Sustainable livelihoods approach was used in: Preparation Studies; Design/Re-design; Learning by Doing; Participative Monitoring; Change Assessment (evaluation); Agreeing Best Practices; Livelihood Assets Analysis; Vulnerability Context Analysis; Trends Analysis; Policy, Institutions and Processes Analysis; Livelihood Strategies Analysis; Livelihood Outcomes Analysis.



Other Urban Development Projects:
Understanding the interface between the environment and sustainable livelihoods in the integration of informal settlements in Asia, Latin America and Africa (Global)
Integrated Urban Housing Development (Kenya and India)
Rural Urban Partnership Programme (RUPP) (Nepal)
Why not contribute?



Contribute:

Livelihoods Connect welcomes details of how sustainable livelihoods approaches are being used by your project. Simply complete the Sustainable Livelihoods Project Summary Form and send it as an email attachment to:

livelihoods-connect@ids.ac.uk.


     

" "DFID logo
" "
" "
  IDS logo" "
" "
" "
Lessons Information Resources Email Update Enquiry Desk Post-it Board PIPs Home Search